Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volume 2 (2): e30. April-June. 2024.
13
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
Review
Pedagogical practice: from the teacher training of the
medical professor.
Guido Manuel Hernández-Paternina
1
.
1
Facultad Nacional de Salud Pública, Universidad de Antioquia, Medellín, Antioquia,
Colombia.
*Corresponding Author: Guido Manuel Hernández-Paternina, Facultad Nacional de Salud
Pública, Universidad de Antioquia, Medellín, Antioquia, Colombia. E-mail:
guidomanuel.hdez@gmail.com. ORCID: 0000-0003-1973-1885
Sent: 11/02/2024 Accepted: 16/04/2024 Published: 16/07/2024
Abstract. This scientific research was conducted based on an analysis of the literature encompassing
pedagogical practice from the perspective of medical teacher training. Reliable information on works
in this field was considered for the research, utilizing bibliographic data, electronic consultations,
scientific articles, and journals. The results obtained highlight the importance of strengthening the
educational efforts in medical sciences through educational practices that guide educators with clear
elements, aiming to address the current societal needs in medical education. The concept of
pedagogical practice is developed according to established axes. Additionally, differences and
similarities between various approaches are identified. Furthermore, a planning approach is
presented to clarify the concept of pedagogical practice from the perspective of the medical teacher.
In conclusion, it is presented that pedagogical practice in the field of medical education possesses
distinctive elements that characterize it and make it applicable in various scenarios within this field.
Keywords: University professor; Medical education; Teacher training; Pedagogical practice.
1. Introduction
Research related to medical education and
its various forms of development within
the university setting is a topic of great
interest in this educational field. It can be
said that this raises concerns when
addressing medical education and,
consequently, the pedagogical practice of
medical educators.
In this regard, it was noted that higher
education teachers, in addition to their
professional training, must possess
pedagogical training that enables them to
guide and adapt teaching-learning
processes in alignment with the goals and
objectives of higher education at the
university level
1
. Therefore, one of the
primary objectives for improving teaching
is related to the planning of pedagogical
training for educators, aiming to integrate
experiences and insights with pedagogical
discussion and debates on theoretical
principles of education. From this
perspective, Bernate and Vargas proposed
that the pedagogical renewal in the 21st
century has generated a reflective
movement on the role of the university
teacher, questioning conceptions,
pedagogical practices, and participation in
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volumen 2 (2): e30. Abril-Junio. 2024.
14
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
sociopolitical processes of change and
social transformation
2
.
Torres described that this century
presents medical education with the
challenge of undertaking a profound
transformation in the continuous training
of its faculty to meet societal demands,
where teacher training and pedagogical
practice constitute a dimension of vital
importance. In this sense, it was
determined that there is a shift in attitudes
toward the pedagogical training of medical
school professors
3
.
Accordingly, investigating the professional
pedagogical practice of medical educators
is of marked relevance in the educational
context, as it facilitates reflection on the
acquisition of knowledge, the
appropriation of pedagogical elements,
and the visibility of the theory-practice
relationship. This approach enables a
pertinent exploration of the construction
of pedagogical knowledge and how it can
be promoted concerning the need for
pedagogical training in the medical field,
specifically highlighting its potential for
medical teaching professionals in
pedagogical practice within this area of
health.
2. Method
In the present scientific research, an
analysis of the literature closest to
pedagogical practice from the perspective
of medical teacher training was
conducted. For this reason, the current
research considered reliable information
from works addressed in this field;
furthermore, bibliographic information,
electronic consultations obtained from e-
books, scientific articles, and journals
were used. This was carried out through a
unified search framework in the following
relevant electronic databases: ERIC, HAPI,
MeSH PubMed, Scielo, EMBASE, and
ScienceDirect, complemented by a free
search in Google Scholar, to obtain
updated information on university
teaching, teacher training, medical
education, and pedagogical practice,
preferably from the last five years and
covering different regions: Europe, North
America, South America, Central America,
and the Caribbean.
Subsequently, the methodology used in
this applied study was descriptive. The
objective was to understand the concept
of pedagogical practice from the
perspective of medical teacher training in
order to guide educational-reflective
intervention by professionals in the
medical field. Additionally, the applied
design was approached from a
documentary perspective, and the data
collection technique used was content
analysis
4
.
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volume 2 (2): e30. April-June. 2024.
15
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
Table 1. Characteristics of the selected studies
Date of publication
Type of publication
Region/country of origin
Year
Number
Type
Number
2023-2020
17
Scientific article
North America
4
2019-2016
17
Disclosure article
South America
24
2015-2012
2
Results article
Central America and
the Caribbean
4
Book
Europe
4
Total
36
36
For the selection of studies, the following
eligibility criteria were established: the
research topic was defined as the
pedagogical practice of the medical
teacher and its relationship with
university teaching, teacher training and
medical education. Out of the 36 studies,
35 were selected. These were then
analyzed in full text in order to identify
how the research addressed the
established components.
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volumen 2 (2): e30. Abril-Junio. 2024.
16
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
Table 2. Selection of the relevant studies
Dimension/topic
Description/findings
Key words
Author(s)
University Teaching
Higher education is related to the capacity to reason efficiently, supported by the cultural and human
considerations that underpin the essence of university educational management. University
professors are professionals who must be highly qualified and possess the necessary experience in
teaching areas.
Professors play a key role in the academic formation and development of university students. They
must have a solid academic background and a deep understanding of the theories and practices in
their respective disciplines. They should possess effective teaching skills and excellent
communication abilities to convey knowledge effectively to university students.
Professors should be capable of designing curricula that are engaging and suitable for university
students; additionally, they should stay updated on the latest advancements and trends in their field
and be able to communicate that knowledge clearly and effectively.
University,
teaching,
university
education,
educational
trends,
university
teacher,
educational
models
Bernate, J. y Vargas, J.
(2020); Colina, A. (2020);
Paredes, M. et al. (2018);
Trillo, F. et al. (2017);
Vera, O. (2016); Vergara
A. (2017)
Teacher training
It encompasses all policies and procedures focused on preparing teachers to acquire the knowledge,
attitudes, and skills necessary to effectively carry out their work in the classroom and the school
community.
It allows educators to develop their educational competencies, appropriate the didactic tools needed
to perform their work in classrooms, and acquire the necessary knowledge to better understand both
the teaching-learning process and the characteristics of interactions with students, regardless of
their area of specialization.
This approach leads to offering students the highest quality and most up-to-date education possible,
making it truly significant. It allows for continuous renewal as the world changes, to provide students
with current and useful knowledge.
Theory of
education,
educational
knowledge,
pedagogy,
pedagogical
knowledge,
pedagogical
training,
teaching
experience,
teaching,
learning
Álvarez, G., et al. (2021),
Charino, N. y Plachot, G.
(2023), Herrera, J. y
Ruíz, A. (2018); Lozano,
E. y Rodríguez, R. (2022);
Macanchí, M. et al
(2020); Martín, (2019);
Orellana, E. et al. (2020);
Suárez et al. (2019);
UNESCO. (2017)
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volume 2 (2): e30. April-June. 2024.
17
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
Table 3. Cont…
Dimension/topic
Description/findings
Key words
Author(s)
Medical Education
Since the principles of Flexner, changes in medical education have necessitated a reevaluation of
training plans to align with the performance expected in the new social, scientific, and professional
context of the medical community.
Medical education is a demanding and complex task, requiring specific pedagogical knowledge in
addition to the scientific knowledge possessed by each medical educator.
In the context of the 21st century, university medical education has distanced itself from the classical
positivist pedagogical model of teaching, where students merely repeat and memorize content
imparted by the teacher.
Medical education is now characterized by continuous efforts to improve the training of future
physicians.
Currently, medical education is moving towards teaching and learning strategies designed to train
autonomous physicians who are capable of adapting to constantly changing contexts, are critical
thinkers, possess collaborative working skills, and are proficient in seeking and selecting information.
Medical schools,
teaching, quality
in medical
education,
medical
curriculum;
Flexner report;
medical
education
Campbell, C. (2017);
Huguet, Y. et al. (2018);
Jara-Gutiérrez, N. et al.
(2015); Morán, (2019);
Patel, M. (2016) Gómez
López, W. (2022);
González, P., y Luna, V.
(2019); Torres, C. (2023);
WMA (2015)
Pedagogical practice
Pedagogical practice involves the ability to manage pedagogical knowledge to ensure that theoretical
knowledge is easily conveyed to learners through the employed methodology.
This practice guides educators towards a perception of their professional performance, focusing on
more technical aspects: planning, didactic contextualization, content management, teaching
strategies, a variety of didactic means, and evaluation.
Pedagogical practice is a means of transforming realities in social contexts, encompassing both the
duty and the essence of being an educator. It enables teachers to implement actions with students to
achieve the expected learning outcomes through various didactic strategies and resources.
It positions the teacher as a creative individual capable of contributing innovative experiences aimed
at facilitating better educational environments, in addition to contributing to the educational field
through teaching, pedagogy, and research.
Furthermore, it involves identifying opportunities to improve the quality of the educational process in
medical sciences.
Pedagogical
practice, didactic
axis, university
didactics,
teaching
experience
Arreola, A; Palmares, G y
Ávila, G. (2019);
Casasola, W. (2020);
Castellano, N. y Díaz, B.
(2020); Cuentas, H., et
al. (2020), Chávez-Vega,
R. (2021); Guerrero C,
Correal-Cuervo R,
Bohórquez-Olaya C,
Burgos-Diaz J, Jaimes-
Bernal C, Montañez-
Torres C., (2023);
Guerrero- Pineda, Y. y
Loaiza, Y. (2018);
Mantilla, G. et al. (2021);
Ripoll-Rivaldo, M. (2021);
Torres, A. y Álvarez, M.,
(2021)
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volumen 2 (2): e30. Abril-Junio. 2024.
18
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
3. Dimensions:
3.1 University profesor
Colina described that "the university is not
limited to the knowledge of skills but to
the integral formation of human
individuals, competent and autonomous in
solving real community problems"
5
;
assuming this as both a principle and a goal
of pedagogical action implies conceiving
higher education not only as a tool but as
the maximum possibility of development.
This requires relying on an educational
experience of complex thinking from the
perspective of didactics, pedagogy, and
the way of approaching knowledge, which
allows teaching to be constituted not only
as an act that trains professionals but also
as integral formation.
It is increasingly necessary and urgent to
define and reinforce the specificity of
university teaching because, in addition to
their normal accumulation of knowledge,
sciences expand their fields, becoming
increasingly complex and diversified. In
this regard, Paul Freire affirmed that
"teaching is not transferring knowledge,
but creating the possibilities for its
production or construction; the one who
teaches learns by teaching, and the one
who learns teaches to learn"
6
. This is
applicable in medicine because a large
amount of knowledge is acquired, but
without an idea of how to adequately
transmit what has been learned.
Similarly, Macanchí et al. described that
the university teacher is responsible for
facilitating, tutoring, advising, managing,
and guiding the learning process; at the
same time, they have the inescapable task
of reviewing initial and continuous
training implications, a key aspect in this
entire process
7
. Additionally, being a
teacher today is not an easy task; today,
teachers are required not only to be
experts in their subject but also to master
teaching techniques, methods, and
strategies, but not solely from a technical
perspective, as expressed by Lozano and
Rodríguez
8
.
In this respect, and as proposed by
Bermejo and Suarez, teaching at any level,
whether in initial education or throughout
university education, including
undergraduate and postgraduate studies,
becomes one of the most complex
activities in society. It has led to the
issuance of a conglomerate of concepts
and theories about how teaching and
learning occur, supported by theoretical
elements from pedagogy, philosophy, and
other sciences
9
.
Similarly, Forero-Jiménez stated that
university education faces increasing
pressures to meet societal needs, where
knowledge constitutes an important
instrument for development
10
. Therefore,
this educational level integrates various
elements such as the institutional project,
academic processes, national and
international visibility, research, relevance
and social impact, well-being, and alumni.
All these elements influence the
achievement of training objectives;
however, it is the teacher who, through
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volume 2 (2): e30. April-June. 2024.
19
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
their teaching action, trains their students,
as they materialize the teaching-learning
process.
3.2 Teacher Training
Teaching related to teacher training is a
demanding and complex task that requires
specific pedagogical knowledge, in
addition to scientific knowledge, as stated
by Charino and Plachot
11
. Generally,
medical teaching has traditionally focused
exclusively on transmitting knowledge to
students through teaching practices that
have been generationally transmitted for a
simple reason: many times, doctors and
other health professionals have not been
taught to be teachers, and programs do
not include teaching and pedagogy topics
in their curricula
12
. In this sense, from the
perspective of teaching in the health field,
as in other knowledge areas, teaching
responds to the demand for constructing
pedagogical knowledge expressed in the
daily practice of training future doctors.
Similarly, the variables addressed from the
concept of pedagogical knowledge are
revisited, and derived from this, the
teaching role and pedagogical practice
according to the context of authors and
perspectives that contemplate these
aspects
13
. Therefore, pedagogical
knowledge arises from a triple relationship
of concepts such as pedagogical practice,
reflection, and the teaching role, where
practice is constituted in everyday life and
reflection. This is a tool to establish the
pedagogical relationship between theory,
practice, and experience.
Today, teaching, like research and the
practice of any profession, demands
specific training. Besides the specific
competencies to practice the profession,
there are competencies related especially
to university teaching, such as mastery of
a knowledge area, pedagogical mastery,
and the exercise of the political dimension
of higher education
14
. This implies
emphasizing that pedagogical training is
extremely relevant for teaching, as it
needs to be adopted as a priority by health
science programs.
In educational practice, various aspects
are combined, such as teacher training,
education, curriculum, didactics,
pedagogy, human development, and
teaching competencies. Thus, complex
thinking in higher education is related to
the capacity to reason efficiently,
supported by cultural and human
considerations that underpin the essence
of university educational management,
articulated in a dialectical relationship
with the accumulated result of knowledge
construction by humanity and the
constant development of scientific
knowledge
15
.
In this same line, Cejas et al. and Ramirez
et al. pointed out that a good teaching
profile is oriented towards communicative
competencies, leadership, emotional
intelligence, teamwork, and the ability to
face complex situations
16,17
. Therefore, the
university teacher must possess three
characteristics: pedagogical,
methodological, and personal
18
.
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volumen 2 (2): e30. Abril-Junio. 2024.
20
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
With these ideas, Lozano and Rodríguez
described that teacher training equates to
the appropriation of teaching culture but
also leads to its transformation
8
. In this
sense, this does not only imply teaching at
an institution; it is not about repeating and
applying what others do or what the
teaching staff has been taught or required
to do in the health field. Consequently,
becoming a teacher means that the
individual has adopted the project of being
a teacher who reflects on it to transform
themselves as a professor, confronting
their old practices, accepted practices and
ideas, and even institutional demands to
improve their teaching role and transform
the teaching culture they are embedded
in.
Therefore, in the context of the 21st
century, it is urgent for university
education to distance itself from the
classical positivist pedagogical model of
teaching, where the student repeats and
memorizes content imparted by the
teacher, prioritizing the teacher's
discourse. Conversely, it is necessary to
transform the unidirectional teacher-
student interaction into a bidirectional
dialectical relationship that surpasses rote
or repetitive learning, advancing towards
meaningful and deep learning, as pointed
out by Gómez-López
1
.
3.3 Medical Education
According to the World Medical
Association [WMA] declaration
19
, medical
education is composed of three stages:
undergraduate university, specialization
or postgraduate studies, and continuous
academic training. In this sense, it is
considered a dynamic and changing
academic and professional continuum
from the first semester in medical schools
until the professional retires. Its main
objective concerning the education of
doctors, whether in training or
specialization, is to prepare them to apply
scientific discoveries and treat diseases.
In this regard, Morán, in the document on
the competencies of the 21st-century
doctor, stated that:
"Adaptive processes to social, economic,
and political contexts are crucial in the
education of future doctors and make it
clear that this training is demanding in
adapting to the new, avant-garde, and
globalized world, whose universal actions
directly impact global health"
20
.
It can be said that perspectives on learning
are important because they influence
almost all decisions about the curriculum,
teaching, and the evaluation process in
medical education. From this perspective,
and from the 1910 Flexner Report on
medical education to the Canadian
definition of medical competencies
outlined in the CanMEDS Framework by
the Royal College of Physicians and
Surgeons of Canada
21
, the profile of a
medical teacher as an innovative and
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volume 2 (2): e30. April-June. 2024.
21
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
creative professional was proposed. This
involves incorporating information
technologies and changing teaching
methods, emphasizing practice and
adjusting evaluation methodologies,
consistent with Torres's description
3
.
Indeed, Huguet proposed that:
"Medical education is that broad and
complex set of events, processes, and
influences, both deliberate and
spontaneous, with which the aspiring
doctor is surrounded from the day they
enter medical school until the end of their
practical life"
12
.
From this, significant changes occurred in
the understanding of the fundamental
aspects of medical education, regarding
effective learning and the professional
attributes required of doctors.
When one wishes to be a medical teacher
within this new conception, Torres's
proposal, describing that learning-
facilitating experiencesteaching-
learning activitiesmust be planned and
not left to chance or randomness, and the
desired changeslearning objectives
must be defined beforehand, as well as the
methodology and evaluation criteria for
learning
3
, must be considered.
Additionally, the ability to communicate,
manage one's emotions, work in a team, do
so with ethical criteria in a multicultural
environment, identify one's training needs
and stay updated, analyze a rapidly
changing environment, and adapt
professionally to it must be taken into
account.
In turn, González and Luna estimated that
medical education is characterized by
constant efforts to improve the training of
future doctors and the care they provide
to patients
22
. From a pedagogical
perspective, we are experiencing an era of
improvement in medical education,
innovative teaching, and the current
teaching methods employed. Similarly,
competency-based learning and passive
lectures have given way to interactive
learning experiences in small groups,
simulation training, procedural skills,
communication skills, and decision-
making, parallel to the growth of scientific
knowledge about health and disease.
Similarly, Orellana et al. warned in their
study that significant changes allowed for
initiatives of important reform in medical
education that may require a broader
conceptualization of the educational
process
23
. In this vein, medicine is a
constantly evolving profession; therefore,
to ensure that medical training aligns with
the continuous evolution of the
profession, multiple transformations
occurred in medical education, including
changes in structure, governance, and
implementation of education, as described
by Gómez-López. In the context of the 21st
century, university medical education has
distanced itself from the classical
positivist pedagogical model of teaching,
where students repeat and memorize
content imparted by the teacher,
prioritizing the teacher's discourse, to
transition to a new competency-based
pedagogical model with a constructivist
approach. This breaks away from the logic
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volumen 2 (2): e30. Abril-Junio. 2024.
22
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
of pure and simple knowledge
transmission, favoring the acquisition of
new knowledge from practice in a given
context1. Indeed, this approach gives
meaning to learning.
Pedagogical Practice
3.4 Pedagogical practice
Talking about pedagogical practice, and
considering what Jara-Gutiérrez et al.
described, requires that the teacher
accounts for their disciplinary and
pedagogical knowledge from their
classroom experiences. This allows them
to identify knowledge construction in the
teacher-student interaction within an
educational framework
24
.
In this regard, Arreola et al. stated:
"It consists of the ability to manage
pedagogical knowledge to make
theoretical knowledge easily accessible to
students through the methodology
employed by the teacher, considering the
group's characteristics, their
contextualization, and current needs"
25
.
Thus, pedagogical practice positions the
teacher as a creative being capable of
contributing innovative experiences
aimed at facilitating better educational
environments, in addition to contributing
to the educational field through teaching,
pedagogy, and research
26
.
Therefore, addressing the theoretical
component in the topic of the pedagogical
practice of medical teachers from teacher
training leads to the conclusion that
educational processes must be carried out
in an analytical, critical, and reflective
manner. Consequently, from an
educational perspective, a teacher's sense
of purpose arises from their previous
experiences, where their pedagogical
practice should be interpreted as a
process of representation, training, and
transformation in response to the new
challenges academia needs
27
. Additionally,
it must be understood that teaching is not
just about transmitting knowledge, as it
must be grounded in a sense of humanity,
rigor, quality, and demand.
Thus, pedagogical practice is considered a
dynamic, changing, and complex tool that
serves as a knowledge strategy and is
directly related to the sociocultural
environment in which the teacher
operates, as well as relationships with
political practice, theories, or disciplines
that support it, among others. Likewise, it
encompasses three methodological
elements: the institution, the subject, and
pedagogical knowledge
28
. Therefore, in the
context of university teaching, teachers
must ensure that students learn new
concepts and not just memorize them.
Indeed, the qualitative difference lies in
teaching students to learn; this is the role
of the university professor: a facilitator of
learning.
Therefore, the teaching role in health
areas is transformative and emancipatory
of its pedagogical practice when reflecting
on its actions, performing a permanent
self-evaluation of each of its learning
models, and consequently questioning its
practical exercise. This responsibility
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volume 2 (2): e30. April-June. 2024.
23
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
transcends to their students, creating
warm and reliable learning environments
where the student is an active, reflective,
and dynamic participant in their
learning
29
.
In this regard, a teacher's sense of purpose
arises from their previous experiences,
where their pedagogical practice should
be interpreted as a process of
representation, training, and
transformation to the new challenges
academia needs
27
. It is also necessary to
understand that teaching not only involves
transmitting knowledge but also must be
grounded in a sense of humanity, rigor,
quality, and demand, which leads to the
transformation of pedagogical knowledge
from pedagogical practice and configuring
the teaching role.
On the other hand, it must be clear that
medical teachers do not usually come
from a pedagogical background, as often
happens in the humanities and teaching
degrees. Instead, they come to the
classroom as a subsequent activity to their
medical practice, not as their main reason
for exercising medical knowledge.
Therefore, the medical teacher faces
challenges in their pedagogical intentions,
where the doctor must primarily be an
expert in the subject and present
themselves as such to their students. They
must be facilitators of their students'
learning, who will become their future
colleagues, instilling in them all the
principles of medical responsibility. A third
challenge is being a model and a teacher of
medical vocation
9
.
In this regard, Bermejo and Suarez
recommended that the role of the doctor
in their pedagogical practice should be
oriented towards reflection and
introspection, and to that extent, critically
reviewing strategies and methodologies to
improve the teaching and learning
processes in their students
9
.
According to Ripoll-Rivaldo, pedagogical
practice is one of the academic processes
that require greater rigor in teacher
training, which is reflected in their
educational management and professional
practice
30
. He also pointed out that the
teacher is recognized as a principal actor
who should direct their formative work
considering values, competencies to be
developed, and a holistic and complex
vision of knowledge.
Similarly, in any disciplinary training
process involving teaching and learning,
the key is achieving a perfect combination
between the rigor of the medical discipline
and good pedagogical practice when
educating future medical professionals31.
In this sense, what the teacher does and
executes becomes important and
fundamental actions to achieve the stated
objective. However, it is common to find
that many medical staff teaching at
universities have strong scientific training
and clinical knowledge of the discipline.
Meanwhile, Torres and Álvarez suggested
that the teaching-educational process is
concretized in the instruction that
expresses the result of the teacher-
student interaction regarding the
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volumen 2 (2): e30. Abril-Junio. 2024.
24
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
assimilation of knowledge and skills
systems, as well as their ability to apply
them creatively and the integral
development of the student. This allows
identifying opportunities to improve the
quality of the teaching-educational
process at the University of Medical
Sciences
32
.
4. Results and Discussion
From the present research, it was
observed that being a higher education
professor underscores the importance of
considering the complexity and plurality
of knowledge involved in university
teaching. Additionally, this implies
contemplating the dimensions proposed
in singular and collective processes to
strengthen, enhance, and revitalize the
role of the teacher for the academic,
educational, and social community. This
perspective aligns with Charino and
Plachot, as it reflects on the commitment
and ethics of teaching practices11. It
involves recognizing this diversity,
generating possibilities for dialogue and
articulation, and constructing specificity
in certain theoretical approaches,
methodological strategies, and areas of
focus through a situated learning process,
the development of university functions,
academic activity, and professional
expertise.
Teacher training, as a field of faculty
development, provides the opportunity to
apply various theories and postulates on
this subject. Likewise, it allows teachers to
take advantage of the training space to
develop multiple skills and abilities that
make them competent professionals,
guiding their work with skills for the
teaching-learning process of their
students. This is consistent with Álvarez et
al., where such training processes enable
teachers to improve their performance
and, consequently, the quality of
teaching
33
. Therefore, these should be
maintained continuously, not only as
training spaces but also as reflections on
pedagogical practice.
According to the results of the
documentary analysis on the
understanding of pedagogical practice
from the perspective of medical teacher
training, advances and contributions with
relevant information on the general
characteristics of university faculty,
teacher training, and medical education
were observed. These allow identifying
critical aspects related mainly to context,
the pedagogical field, the teaching-
learning process, and teaching practice.
These, in turn, greatly contribute to
guaranteeing the quality of medical
education.
In this regard, medical education and the
pedagogical practice of medical
professors, in the years since the Flexner
study, have allowed an understanding that
almost all aspects of pedagogy have
evolved in three major ways: the roles of
teacher and student have changed; the
dynamic nature of teaching and learning
has become evident, both in individual and
collective aspects; and finally, the
importance of the environment in
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volume 2 (2): e30. April-June. 2024.
25
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
supporting learning has been highlighted.
This has enabled medical educators to
have new ways of thinking about
themselves, their work, and their
relationships with learning and students.
Therefore, it could be said that this aligns
with what Gómez-López proposed
1
.
With the process of globalization, there is
a significant transformation in the role of
the medical teacher and the need for them
to be trained to contribute to the quality
and innovation of medical education. This,
in turn, allows the application of the most
advanced tools to ensure superior
educational management with modern
methodologies that ultimately influence
the quality of graduates and their future
actions in the community. Hence, teacher
training is crucial for the quality of the
educational process and society. This
aligns with the United Nations
Educational, Scientific, and Cultural
Organization (UNESCO)
34
, which indicated
that "if the teacher does not change,
significant changes in educational
processes to meet social demands cannot
be made."
Furthermore, pedagogical practice is the
scenario where the teacher accounts for
their disciplinary and pedagogical
knowledge based on their classroom
experiences. This allows them to identify
knowledge construction in the teacher-
student interaction within an educational
framework. Thus, pedagogical practice
positions the teacher as a creative being
capable of contributing innovative
experiences aimed at facilitating better
educational environments and
contributing to the educational field
through teaching, pedagogy, and research,
as proposed by Guerrero et al.
35
.
In medicine, pedagogical practice and
innovative teaching methods coincide
with what Pineda and Loaiza formulated
28
,
who emphasized that the formulation of
didactic or teaching models, beyond
hegemonic paradigms, contributes to
evolutionary and relativistic views of
knowledge and, in that sense, builds social
value related to the commitment and
responsibility that facilitate the
development of professional
competencies in students.
4. Conclusions
From the previous interpretations and
findings, it was highlighted that higher
education presents significant challenges
in a world of continuous changes that
demand reflection on the formative
purpose of institutions. This is essential to
respond to the needs of the environment
and society in this new century, where
topics such as quality, the teaching-
learning process, teacher training, and
pedagogical models must be considered.
For this reason, teacher training is
essential to provide quality education and
ensure the future success of students. This
corresponds to the responsibility that
teachers have to transmit knowledge and
skills that are essential for student
development. This practice is not only
about acquiring new skills but also about
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volumen 2 (2): e30. Abril-Junio. 2024.
26
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
helping teachers improve their teaching
and motivate their medical students.
Following the documentary analysis
conducted in the time since Flexner's
principles, changes in medical practices
have necessitated a reevaluation of
training plans to meet the expected
performance in the new social, scientific,
and professional context of the medical
community.
Moreover, as has been corroborated,
pedagogical practice requires conceptual,
procedural, and strategic preparation
from teachers. This preparation should
lead professors to reflect on daily life and
how to intervene with theoretical
concepts and bring them to life to meet
the challenges of pedagogical practice in
line with the ever-evolving needs of
medical sciences.
Therefore, the use of active pedagogies by
teachers energizes the teaching and
learning process, allowing them to go
beyond traditional methods and,
consequently, transition to an educational
model based on the theory of complex
thinking. This is related to the positive
valuation of their experience, which allows
them to identify how this practice
contributes to the formative process of
students and the continuous improvement
of their pedagogical practices.
In summary, it is necessary to advance in
developing dynamic and flexible tools that
enable the establishment of the degree of
knowledge of medical teachers
concerning the established pedagogical
model. Additionally, there needs to be
coherence in their actions when executing
teaching knowledge and the evaluation
styles used in the process, which
determine the efficiency of their teaching
with quality in any scenario of medical
education.
5. Statements
5.1 Conflict of interest
The author states that there is no conflict
of interest that could bias the results or
the interpretation of the study.
5.2 Funding
Non-monetary
5.3 Acknowledgments
To my family and to the Universities of
Antioquia in Medellin Colombia and Baja
California in Mexico.
References
1. Gómez-López W. La Educación Médica
en el Siglo XXI. Revista De Investigación
Ciencias De La Salud. 2022; 2(3): p. 12-17.
2. Bernate, J. & Vargas, J. Desafíos y
tendencias del siglo XXI en la educación
superior. Revista de Ciencias Sociales.
2020; 26.
3. Torres C. Educación médica en
Colombia y propuestas de cambio.
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volume 2 (2): e30. April-June. 2024.
27
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
Ciencia Latina Revista Científica
Multidisciplinar. 2023 Abril; 7(2): p. 97-
108.
4. Arias F. El Proyecto de Investigación
Introducción a la metodología científica
(7a ed) Caracas: Editorial Episteme, C.A.,;
2016.
5. Colina A. La educación superior desde la
visión del pensamiento complejo.
Científica Ecociencia. 2020 Febrero; 7.
6. Vergara A. El papel del docente, el
ejemplo y el maestro en la enseñanza de
la medicina. Revista Colombiana de
Cirugía. 2017 Febrero; 32(1): p. 9-11.
7. Macanchí, M; Orozco, B; Campoverde,
M. Innovación educativa, pedagógica y
didáctica. Concepciones para la práctica
en la educación superior. Revista
Universidad y Sociedad. 2020; 12(1).
8. Lozano E, Rodríguez R. Vocación y
formación docente en el área de la salud:
impulsos para la transformación. Revista
Docencia Universitaria. 2022 Enero-
Junio; 23(1): p. 23-43.
9. Bermejo F, Suarez M. La función
pedagógica del médico docente como
oportunidad. Anamnesis y tratamiento.
Educación Médica. 2019; 22(5).
10. Forero-Jiménez MY. Modelo de
responsabilidad social universitaria: una
propuesta para las instituciones
colombianas. Revista de Investigación,
Desarrollo e Innovación. 2019; 9(2): p.
249-260.
11. Charino N, Plachot G. Pluralidad de
saberes en la formación docente
universitaria. Investigaciones y
experiencias. 2023 Diciembre; 10(2): p.
2-10.
12. Huguet Y. Preparación de profesores en
ciencias médicas: Una visión desde las
páginas de Edumecentro. Revista de
Educación Médica del Centro. 2018 Julio;
10(3).
13. Herrera J, Ruíz A. El saber pedagógico
como saber práctico. Pedagogía y
Saberes. 2018 Julio;(49): p. 9-26.
14. Vera O. El nuevo modelo docente
universitario en medicina. Revista
"Cuadernos". 2016; 57(1): p. 59-64.
15. Paredes M, López Z, Velasteguí E.
Mirando hacia el futuro con
pensamiento complejo en la educación
superior. Ciencia Digital. 2018; 1(1): p. 2-
22.
16. Cejas M, Mendoza D, Alban C, Frias É.
Caracterización del perfil de las
competencias laborales en el docente
universitario. Revista Orbis. 2020
Julio;(45): p. 23-37.
17. Ramirez-Asis E, Espinoza M, Esquivel S,
Naranjo-Toro M. Inteligencia emocional,
competencias y desempeño del docente
universitario: Aplicando la técnica
mínimos cuadrados parciales SEM-PLS.
Revista electrónica interuniversitaria de
formación del profesorado, 23(3): p. 99-
114.
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volumen 2 (2): e30. Abril-Junio. 2024.
28
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
18. Alonso-Martín P. El perfil del buen
docente universitario según la
valoración de alumnos de Magisterio y
Psicopedagogía. Perfiles Educativos.
2019; 41(164): p. 65-79.
19. Asociación Médica Mundial [WMA].
Competencias y perfiles del médico.
[Online].; 2015. Available from:
https://www.wma.net/es/.
20. Morán J. Competencias del médico del
siglo XXI. Un cambio necesario. Rev.
Cient. Cienc. Salud. 2019; 1(2): p. 58-73.
21. Campbell C. Developing teachers’
professional learning: Canadian
evidence and experiences in a world of
educational improvement. Canadian
Journal of Education. 2017; 40(2): p. 1-33.
22. González P, Luna V. La transformación
de la educación médica en el último
siglo: innovaciones curriculares y
didácticas (parte 1). Investigación En
Educación Médica. 2019 Abril; 8(30): p.
95-109.
23. Orellana EO, Juanes BY, Orellana O,
Orellana F. Formación pedagógica de los
docentes de la carrera de medicina en
Ecuador. Universidad y Sociedad. 2020;
12(3): p. 176-184.
24. Jara-Gutiérrez N, Díaz- López MM,
Zapata-Castañeda PN. Desafíos
educativos para el profesor de medicina:
evaluación de su desempeño. Iatreia.
2015 Julio ; 28(3): p. 292-299.
25. Arreola A, Palmares G, Ávila G. La
práctica pedagógica desde la
socioformación. Revista RAES. 2019;
11(18): p. 74-87.
26. Guerrero C, Correal-Cuervo R,
Bohórquez-Olaya C, Burgos-Diaz J,
Jaimes-Bernal C, Montañez-Torres C.
Modelo educativo, prácticas
pedagógicas y valoraciones de docentes
en educación superior. Educación y
Humanismo. 2023 Julio; 25(45): p. 205-
223.
27. Castellano N, Díaz B. Calidad de la
Práctica Pedagógica del Docente
Universitario. Revista Científica
Electrónica de Negocios. 2020 Julio;
16(46): p. 42-52.
28. Pineda Y, Loaiza Y. Estado del arte de las
prácticas pedagógicas de los maestros
de las Escuelas Normales Superiores y
las Facultades de Educación. Praxis.
2018; 14(2): p. 265-285.
29. Trillo F, Nieto JM, Martínez B, Escudero
JM. El Desarrollo Profesional y la
Colaboración Docente: Un Análisis
Situado en el Contexto Español de las
Tensiones y Fracturas Entre la Teoría y
la Práctica. Archivos Analíticos de
Políticas Educativas. 2017; 25(117): p. 2-
23.
30. Ripoll-Rivaldo M. Prácticas pedagógicas
en la formación docente: desde el eje
didáctico. Telos. 2021 Mayo-Agosto;
23(2): p. 286-299.
Horizon Interdisciplinary Journal (HIJ). ISSN: 2992-7706
Volume 2 (2): e30. April-June. 2024.
29
Https://doi.org/10.56935/hij.v2i2.30
31. Mantilla G, Ariza K, Santamaria A,
Moreno S. Educación médica basada en
competencias: Revisión de enfoque.
Universitas Medica. 2021; 62(2): p. 1-12.
32. Torres A, Álavarez M. El desempeño
profesional del médico docente en la
asignatura Medicina Interna. Atenas:
Revista Científico Pedagógica. 2021;
53(1): p. 71-86.
33. Álvarez G, Viteri J, Estupiñán J, Viteri C.
La formación continua de los docentes
de la educación superior como sustento
del modelo pedagógico. Revista
Conrado. 2021; 17(S1): p. 431-439.
34. Organización de las Naciones Unidas
para la Educación, la Ciencia y la Cultura
[UNESCO]. Formación docente.
Educación Superior y Sociedad. 2017; 9.
35. Guerrero HR, Morales Y, Nuñez GP,
Medina ED. Impacto de la
resignificación de la práctica pedagógica
investigativa y del currículo de
graduados de pedagogía de
instituciones de educación superior en
Barranquilla-Colombia. Formación
Universitaria. 2020; 13(2): p. 29-38.
Copyright © Guido Manuel Hernández-Paternina 2024
This text is under a Creative Commons BY 4.0 license
You are free to Share - copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format
and Adapt the content - remix, transform, and build upon the material for any
purpose, even commercially under the following terms:
Attribution
:
You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and
indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in
any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use.
CC BY 4.0 license terms summary CC BY 4.0 license terms